A Historic Shift in Homeownership: What the Decline in First-Time Buyers Means for the U.S. Housing Market

The U.S. housing market is experiencing a profound shift marked by tightening affordability, evolving demographics, and a declining share of first-time homebuyers. These changes are influencing everything from new home constructiontrends to long-term real estate investment strategies. As the industry adapts, understanding these developments is critical for builders, investors, and policymakers navigating today’s rapidly evolving landscape.

First-Time Homebuyers Reach a Record Low

Recent findings from the National Association of REALTORS® reveal that first-time homebuyers now represent just 21% of U.S. home purchases, the lowest level ever documented. This decline is accompanied by a rising median first-time buyer age of 40, a significant increase from the early 30s just a decade ago.

Factors Driving the Shift

• Elevated home prices

• Higher mortgage rates

• Limited existing home inventory

• Increased down payment requirements

Together, these factors are redefining the timeline and accessibility of homeownership for American households.

---

A Widening Housing Wealth Gap

The growing divide between first-time buyers and repeat buyers is reshaping U.S. housing market trends.

Repeat buyers are entering transactions with significantly greater financial leverage. Their median down payment of 23%, compared to 10% for first-time buyers, underscores the long-term impact of having accumulated equity. Additionally, 30% of repeat buyers purchase homes with cash, capitalizing on market conditions that favor liquidity.

Delaying homeownership carries substantial financial consequences — postponing a purchase from age 30 to 40 results in an estimated $150,000 in lost equity, reinforcing the urgency of improving pathways to homeownership.

New Home Construction: A Path Toward Affordability

One of the most promising developments in the 2025 housing market is the rising affordability of new construction homes.

For the first time in several years, the median price of a new home has dropped below that of an existing home. This shift reflects industry-wide adjustments aligned with buyers’ priorities.

Affordability-Driven Builder Strategies

• 41% of builders reduced prices in November — the highest share since the post-COVID period.

• 65% of builders offered incentives, including mortgage rate buydowns and closing-cost support.

These trends highlight a strong commitment to delivering attainable housing options despite ongoing market headwinds.

Smaller, More Efficient Home Designs

Homebuilders are also optimizing home design to enhance affordability. The median new-home size decreased to 2,150 sq. ft., the smallest in 15 years, signaling a shift toward efficient layouts and consumer-focused features.

These changes position new construction as an increasingly viable option for buyers who may otherwise be priced out of the market.

Strategic Implications for Residential Development

The evolving landscape presents opportunities for organizations committed to long-term housing solutions. Rising affordability challenges are driving demand for well-designed communities that accommodate diverse stages of life and meet modern expectations for efficiency, value, and accessibility.

At Walton Global, we recognize the crucial role of strategic land development in expanding access to homeownership. Our approach includes:

• Securing land positions in high-growth U.S. markets

• Collaborating with builders focused on attainable and efficient housing solutions

• Designing communities aligned with current and future buyer needs

By anticipating the direction of the housing market and investing in forward-thinking development strategies, Walton is helping shape the next generation of residential communities.

To explore Walton Global’s current land offerings and real estate investment strategies, visit walton.com.